Charcoal Incense vs Wood Pulp Incense: Which One Is Better?

Charcoal and wood pulp incense sticks offer different benefits and drawbacks. Charcoal incense sticks are known for their excellent fragrance throw and absorption, while wood pulp incense sticks are commonly made from natural materials that influence the scent and burn properties. When choosing unscented incense sticks, it’s important to consider the material’s impact on your overall experience, health, and environment.

What are Unscented Incense Sticks?

Unscented incense sticks are a popular choice for those who enjoy the ritual of burning incense but may be sensitive to certain fragrances. There are two main types of unscented incense sticks: unscented charcoal incense sticks and unscented wood pulp incense sticks. In this section, you’ll gain an understanding of these two types of incense sticks and their differences.

Unscented charcoal incense sticks are made from a mixture of charcoal powder and a binding agent, usually made of natural materials, such as gum Arabic or tragacanth. The charcoal helps the incense stick burn consistently and evenly. While charcoal incense sticks don’t have any added fragrances, they may still produce a faint scent due to the burning process of the charcoal itself. These sticks are ideal for use with resins or loose, aromatic herbs that you’d like to burn on their own without mixing with other scents.

On the other hand, unscented wood pulp incense sticks are made from a blend of wood powders, typically sourced from sustainable tree species like sandalwood, and a natural binder, such as bamboo. These incense sticks provide a subtle, natural wood scent when burned, making them perfect for those who prefer a more subdued aroma or want to use them with essential oils or other types of fragrances.

When choosing between unscented charcoal incense sticks and unscented wood pulp incense sticks, consider your personal preferences and how you plan to use them. If you’re looking for a completely neutral base to use with other fragrances, charcoal incense sticks may be a better choice for you. However, if a mild, natural wood scent is what you’re after, then wood pulp incense sticks may be the ideal option.

Remember to follow safety guidelines when burning unscented incense sticks, such as using a proper incense holder or tray, keeping them away from flammable materials, and not leaving them unattended while lit. Enjoy the calming ambiance and simplicity of unscented incense sticks as part of your daily rituals or meditation practice.

How do you use unscented incense sticks?

Using unscented incense sticks is quite simple and easy. With a few steps, you’ll be able to create your own customized scent blends to enhance your surroundings. Here’s a step-by-step guide on using unscented incense sticks:

1. Gather your supplies: First, gather all the necessary supplies including unscented incense sticks, essential oils, a non-reactive container, a pair of gloves, and a surface area for the incense sticks to dry. Make sure your work area is clean and well-ventilated.

2. Choose your essential oils: Your choice of essential oils is crucial in creating the desired scent. Some popular choices include lavender, sandalwood, and lemon, but feel free to mix and match according to your preferences. Use 20 drops of essential oils per incense stick.

3. Prepare the scent mixture: In the non-reactive container, mix the essential oils thoroughly. If blending different types, ensure they’re complementary to achieve a balanced fragrance outcome.

4. Dip and soak the unscented incense sticks: Wearing gloves, immerse the unscented incense sticks into the container with the essential oil mixture. Allow the sticks to soak for a few minutes, then gently rotate them to ensure even coverage.

5. Dry the incense sticks: After dipping, place the treated incense sticks on a clean surface area, ensuring they don’t touch each other while drying. It’s essential to allow the incense sticks to dry thoroughly for at least a day, but up to three days is recommended for better absorption of the essential oils.

6. Light the incense stick: Finally, it’s time to enjoy your custom-scented incense sticks! To do so, use a lighter or match to ignite the coated end of the incense stick. Let the flame burn for a few seconds before gently blowing it out, allowing the incense stick to smolder and release the delightful aroma.

Remember, practice makes perfect – feel free to experiment with a variety of essential oils and proportions when creating your customized incense sticks. With each batch, you’ll continue to refine your process and discover new blends that best suit your preferences.

Unscented Charcoal Incense Vs Unscented Wood Pulp Incense

Composition and Production

When considering unscented charcoal incense and unscented wood pulp incense, it’s essential to understand their composition and production process. Charcoal incense sticks are mainly made from powdered charcoal and are known to be excellent at absorbing fragrances. On the other hand, wood pulp incense sticks are typically made from wood powder combined with a binder.

The production process for both types of incense sticks also varies. While making charcoal incense, the powdered charcoal is mixed with water and a binder, rolled onto a bamboo stick, and left to dry. In comparison, wood pulp incense is made by blending the wood powder with water and a binder, rolling the mixture onto a bamboo stick, and allowing it to dry.

Aroma and Burn Quality

Since both types of incense sticks are unscented, it’s crucial to focus on their burn quality. Unscented charcoal incense sticks are known for their strong absorption properties, so you can expect a consistent burn and the ability to hold a fragrance well if you later decide to add one. In contrast, unscented wood pulp incense may not be as effective at absorbing scents due to its wood powder composition.

As for burn quality, charcoal incense tends to have a cleaner burn and produces less smoke than wood pulp incense, making them a better option if you’re concerned about air quality. Wood pulp incense, when burned, may produce more smoke and have a woodier scent due to the wood powder content.

In conclusion, the choice between unscented charcoal incense and unscented wood pulp incense comes down to personal preferences and intended use. If you’re looking for a cleaner burn, better absorption, and the option to add a fragrance later, charcoal incense might be the better choice. However, if you prefer a more natural, woodsy aroma and don’t mind a bit of extra smoke, wood pulp incense could be the way to go.

Here is a video comparison on unscented charcoal incense sticks VS wood pulp incense sticks

Pros and Cons of Unscented Charcoal Incense

Environmental Impact

When it comes to the environment, unscented charcoal incense has a smaller footprint compared to wood pulp incense. Since charcoal incense is made from a sustainable plant-based material, it’s generally considered to be more eco-friendly. Wood pulp incense, on the other hand, contributes to deforestation, and its production can result in the usage of harmful chemicals. So, if you’re looking for a more environmentally friendly option, unscented charcoal incense would be a better choice.

Health Concerns

While both charcoal and wood pulp incense emit smoke when burned, there are differences in the potential health effects. Charcoal incense tends to produce less smoke, which can be beneficial for individuals with respiratory issues or allergies. However, it’s important to remember that any type of smoke can be harmful if exposed to it for long periods, so moderation is key. In comparison, wood pulp incense produces more smoke and may contain chemicals from its production process, which could be harmful when inhaled. Stick to high-quality, natural unscented charcoal incense to minimize health risks.

Ease of Use

Using unscented charcoal incense can be a bit more challenging, as it requires a separate heat source like a charcoal tablet to burn effectively. You’ll need to light the tablet, wait for it to heat up, and then add a pinch of incense to release the fragrance. This process can take a bit more time and effort than simply lighting a wood pulp incense stick.

On the other hand, the versatility of unscented charcoal incense allows you to create your own unique scent combinations by mixing different herbs or resins. Plus, this type of incense typically burns for a longer duration, providing a more sustained aromatic experience. Just be patient, and you’ll find that using unscented charcoal incense can become a rewarding and enjoyable ritual.

Pros and Cons of Unscented Wood Pulp Incense


When it comes to sustainability, wood pulp incense has a few advantages. It’s generally made from renewable and naturally abundant materials, which means you can enjoy this incense without causing significant harm to the environment. However, it’s essential to ensure that the wood pulp used is sourced from responsibly managed forests, not contributing to deforestation.

Health Benefits

While most incense is composed of natural materials, some may contain synthetic components that can be harmful when inhaled over long periods (source: East West Seattle). Wood pulp incense is typically created from natural ingredients like wood, resins, and oils. This means that, in general, your wood pulp incense should be safer to burn and less likely to cause any adverse health effects. However, it’s essential to ensure the specific incense you use is free from harmful additives or synthetic components.

Burning Characteristics

Wood pulp incense has some unique burning characteristics when compared to other types of incense. It tends to burn more quickly than charcoal-based incense due to its thinner shape . The quicker burn rate can be beneficial if you prefer a shorter burning session or wish to change scents frequently. On the downside, this faster burn might cause more smoke, which could be an issue for those sensitive to smoke or have allergies. In terms of fragrance throw, it’s worth noting that some people believe charcoal incense may perform better (source: Craft Server). However, personal preferences and the quality of individual incense sticks may significantly influence this aspect.

What are charcoal incense sticks used for?

Charcoal incense sticks are popular for their ability to absorb and release fragrances effectively. When using charcoal incense sticks, you can easily experience a more intense and long-lasting aroma than with other types of incense sticks.

The primary purpose of using charcoal incense is to create a pleasing and relaxing atmosphere in your surroundings. They are often used for meditation, aromatherapy, and spiritual practices, as well as simply to enjoy their pleasant scent. Charcoal incense sticks are a great option to burn natural resin incenses like frankincense and myrrh, which require a strong heat source to release their full potential of fragrance.

Moreover, they can serve as a natural insect repellent, keeping mosquitoes and other pests at bay while providing a pleasant aroma. This can be especially helpful during the warm summer months or when spending time outdoors.

Another benefit of charcoal incense sticks is their ability to effectively cleanse the energy in your space. Burning these incense sticks can help remove negative energies and create a more balanced and harmonious environment.

In comparison to wood pulp incense, charcoal incense sticks have a reputation for better fragrance throw and absorption. This means that the scent of charcoal incense is typically stronger and more noticeable than that of wood pulp incense.

So, when you’re looking to create a calming atmosphere, repel insects, or cleanse the energy in your space, consider using charcoal incense sticks for their potent and long-lasting fragrance. Remember always to handle them with care, and enjoy the many benefits they can offer you in various settings.

Price Comparison

When you’re looking to buy incense sticks, price is an important aspect to consider. In this section, we’ll compare the costs of unscented charcoal incense sticks to unscented wood pulp incense sticks.

Unscented charcoal incense sticks can usually be found at a relatively affordable price, but the price may vary depending on the brand and quantity. For example, a pack of 1000 charcoal-based incense sticks costs around $14.95 on Amazon.

On the other hand, unscented wood pulp incense sticks are also budget-friendly. You can find 5 bundles of 500 unscented wood pulp incense sticks at a slightly lower price of $14.95 on Amazon, as well. However, always keep in mind that prices may fluctuate, so it’s essential to compare prices periodically.

Here’s a quick overview of the price comparison between unscented charcoal and unscented wood pulp incense sticks:

  • Unscented Charcoal Incense Sticks:
    • 1000 sticks – $14.95
  • Unscented Wood Pulp Incense Sticks:
    • 2500 sticks (5 bundles of 500) – $14.95

It’s important to note that these are merely examples to give you an idea of the price range. Actual prices might differ based on factors like brand, seller, or ongoing discounts. So, make sure to always double-check and compare prices before making a purchasing decision.

When comparing prices, remember that sometimes cheaper doesn’t always mean better. Some factors to consider when buying incense sticks are quality, quantity, and how long they burn. So don’t just focus on the price, but also take into account the overall value you’re getting with your purchase.

Scroll to Top